The Talon

Vol. 1 | Ed. 15

Loading date...
Fetching weather...

Teaching the Tech

“The real problem is not whether machines think but whether men do.” -B.F. Skinner

In the 2020’s, the world had an idea. “How amazing would it be if there was an app to do all my work for me?” This is an idea that has come into fruition mere years ago with the invention of artificial intelligence. AI had a big boom in 2022, when ChatGPT was released. ChatGPT is essentially a generative, conversational bot, accessible to anyone with a smartphone, tablet, or computer, and is free of charge. As AI technology improved, it became more and more user-friendly, particularly to teens and students. According to Campbell University, as of March 2025, up to 86% of students were using AI for their studies. This year, the American Psychological Association states that “more than half of U.S. adolescents use AI chatbots for schoolwork”. As a high school student, I personally believe AI is ruining society and our progress in evolution. Let’s hear from some more students and teachers about that.

A freshman student at Flagstaff High School, Yesenia Hernandez, was one of the three subjects I interviewed. When asked about her opinion on using AI technologies for schoolwork, she stated, she “will only use it if a teacher instructs it”. She went on to say she first remembers AI becoming a topic in school settings in seventh grade, when she was first instructed to use it for an assignment. However, she believes that using AI is unnecessary most of the time. When questioned about how she feels about the increased use of AI, she said she believes “AI is taking our ability to think and learn”.

Gabriella Garcia, a senior student, was the second interviewee. This time, when I asked about how she feels about using AI for schoolwork, the student said she will use it for grammar and spell checks. Although, she continued on to say she believes that “people should think for themselves” and that AI is “something that not a lot of people should use”. When I asked about how she feels about the increased use of AI, she said it is scary how much AI has grown. She said she doesn’t like how it is the “main thing talked about” by teachers and students recently. She believes that AI technology will improve, but students misusing it will not.

Finally, I interviewed Mr. Williams, an English teacher at Flagstaff High School. Every time he was asked how he feels about AI usage, he said he was “entirely opposed”. He stated that while change in technology is inevitable, AI is “taking things we need for sustenance”. He compared using AI to eating fast food: a short-lived happiness and relief, and no real effort put into it. While it might be quick and easy, fast food has zero health benefits or value in the long run—neither does AI.

He stated that he first remembers AI being used by students in 2022, when ChatGPT came out. He recalls one of his students writing an essay using ChatGPT, and it was just as obvious then as it is now that it wasn’t a student’s work. Williams said, “if we prioritize it…it is going to have awful effects on our minds and our bodies”.

In the words of Mr. Williams, I too believe that “we have put way too much stock in [AI]…solving our problems, and it is going to blow up in our face”. As we’ve been told by our wonderful interviewees, many students and teachers believe that AI is taking away creativity, independent thinking, and personal innovation from the world. However, all interviewees stated that there are certain forms of AI they will accept; algorithmic AI, spelling and grammar check AI…but where do we draw the line? Where do you draw the line?