The Talon
Vol. 1 | Ed. 17
Behind Bars
On March 29, 2023, journalist Evan Gershkovich walked into an American steakhouse restaurant in Yekaterinburg, Russia, seemingly to interview Pavel, a tank factory union boss, for a story he was doing on Russia’s military. Pavel handed him confidential documents about the Russian military and walked him through them. Suddenly, around half a dozen men walked inside and confronted him. They were the FSB, Russia’s federal security service, meant to maintain security inside Russia and neutralize any threats posed to the state. Evan was stupefied—the FSB were notorious for using cruel tactics and interrogation methods to get information from spies and enemies, and if he was unlucky enough to be accused of treason, then he might be in for a wild ride.
On August 1st, 2024, the Wall Street Journal reporter was released by Russian officials after being falsely imprisoned for 16 months. As part of a Russian-American prisoner exchange, Evan Gershkovich was freed early from his 16-year sentence for espionage charges as claimed by Russia. Turns out, Evan was never guilty of the allegations, and neither did Russia actually suspect him. This was merely all part of their plan to maximize profit for the upcoming prisoner swap with America. Evan, along with some other detained Americans, was never seriously tortured or treated like an enemy of the nation, but was only seen as a tradable commodity to Russia. Just a few weeks ago, Evan published a personal memoir called This Cursed Beautiful Land, speaking up about his false imprisonment, his coping mechanisms, and the beautiful culture and language he learned during his stay. There, he dedicated his time to reading, writing, and reporting, treating his imprisonment in Lefortovo, Moscow, as an opportunity to gain insight into Russia's cultural beauty and relationships between peers throughout his time spent there. Evan talks about how he and his cellmate, nicknamed “Seryoga,” bonded deeply within the prison walls, where they would play backgammon and watch TV—whereas he never thought they could have done the same outside of it. He also reflects on his own imprisonment, saying, “The only suitable place for an honest man in Russia… is prison,” reflecting on his book and how lucky he is compared to other journalists to be released alive. In an NPR All Things Considered interview, he compares himself to a Ukrainian journalist, Viktoria Roshchyna, who instead got “killed in prison and returned in a body bag” around the same time when he got detained. According to the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), CEO Jodie Ginsberg states, “They were detained and sentenced on spurious charges intended to punish them for independent reporting.”
The story and memoir of Evan Gershkovich have fueled an already big realization within American society, questioning us about our true values regarding how we, as a whole, view our constitutional rights and where we and other nations truly cross the line on human rights. When Ms. Perugini was asked about the importance of press freedom in America, she explained how press freedom allows journalists to criticize the government and authorities to hold them accountable for their actions. She also mentioned the importance of correct and unbiased journalism in the U.S. and how we as a nation should be able to identify and understand the current state of our country. She used examples such as CNN and certain news stations being removed from White House press conferences and talked about how it could potentially lead to prejudiced news. Finally, when questioned on the risks of international reporting, she responded by saying how other foreign countries, such as North Korea and China, have a different view of rights than we do, and that can be very dangerous, as many have been reported as missing or detained for those reasons. In the end, Evan’s story also acts as a mirror we can reflect on—about what America stands for and what it truly means to have these constitutional rights. There are recently countless cases of journalists and news stations in our nation being banned and caught in legal issues, with prime examples being CNN and other journalists from news outlets being barred from the White House over allegations of spreading false information, and journalists and civilians being actively assaulted during immigration-related situations, with videos showing them being pushed and even thrown.
In conclusion, the story of Evan Gershkovich is only one of many about journalists being affected by government officials and law enforcement, raising questions on how our government should treat journalists to keep official and crucial information accurate and unbiased.